I gave this coat as gift.
It?s a good looking coat and appears to be of good quality.
I?m told it?s very warm, even hot if temps are holding at 30F with the liner in.
I purchased a size Medium for a gent at 5?5? and 175 lbs. It?s a great fit with some wiggle room.
I stay on the cold side, even indoors, so I wear fleece jackets every day. This one is very warm, great for sitting and reading. Also good for spring and fall strolls. Lining rustles quite a bit, which may be why it's on sale. If that doesn't bother you, I highly recommend it.